Case study

A $37 million screenshot. Almost nothing behind it.

A New York crypto adviser told investors their money was in discounted tokens. When the payouts stopped, he texted one of them a wallet worth $37.8 million and asked him to keep it quiet. Our team proved the screenshot was staged, followed the money to the exchanges, and then answered the question nobody else could: everyone knew who he was, but not where he was.

EXTRADITED · ON TRIALArrested at Heathrow on an Interpol red notice. He is not named here.

Read the case
Shown in the screenshot
$37.8M

Shown in the screenshot

Signs it was staged
6

Signs it was staged

Repeats of one cash-out pattern
7

Repeats of one cash-out pattern

Extradition
1

Extradition

The brief

What the investors had.

More than 250 people had trusted him with their savings. Here is what they, and his own bankruptcy filings, could hand our team.

THE PITCH

Discounted tokens

He told more than 250 investors, elderly savers among them, that their money bought tokens at a discount through his advisory firm. About $4.4 million went in.
THE SCREENSHOT

$37.8 million, in confidence

When payouts stopped, he texted one investor a wallet screenshot and asked him to keep it to himself.
THE BANKRUPTCY

A hack, on paper

He filed for bankruptcy and told his creditors a hack had taken the funds. The screenshot, he said, showed the wallet before the hack.
THE REPORTS

Transaction reports

To back the story he produced Coinbase transaction reports from 2016 to 2019, listing 11 addresses he had sent funds to.

Part one · His evidence

Six things the screenshot left out.

We rebuilt the wallet screen it came from and compared the two. Every missing piece hid something about where the money really was.

Private61
LOGO SCROLLED OUT OF FRAME2
TOTAL BALANCE
$37,851,617.56
CEL8,000,100$37,006,849.10
BTC13$830,046.10
ETH3$13,722.36
?Hidden wallet5$1,000.00
MY DEPOSIT ADDRESS3
0x••••…•••• never used
Previous addresses: not shown4
A redrawing of the screenshot he sent, with its balances as shown. The numbered signs match the list.
  1. 1
    The URL was deleted.

    The address bar is empty, so the site is not named.

  2. 2
    The logo was scrolled away.

    The page sits just low enough to cut off the wallet's branding.

  3. 3
    The deposit address was brand new.

    It had never received a transaction. The wallet makes fresh addresses on demand, which hides the one in real use.

  4. 4
    The address history was hidden.

    The interface can list every address the account has used. None were shown.

  5. 5
    One wallet was hidden.

    A fourth holding, worth $1,000, had its currency masked.

  6. 6
    It was a private window.

    Taken in an incognito session, so nothing stayed signed in.

IDENTIFIED

A custodial wallet

Search work matched the layout to Freewallet, a hosted wallet that holds its users' keys and requires an email to sign up. A company that holds keys can be subpoenaed.
REBUILT

Our own account, side by side

We opened an account on the same service and compared it screen by screen. That is how the six missing pieces stood out.
DATED

The prices gave the date

CEL shows at $4.63. Matching every price on screen to market history put the capture between October 16 and November 20, 2021, most likely October 29, when CEL closed at $4.6297.
THE REPORTS

The transaction reports did not add up either.

Rebuilt from his own Coinbase reports, the account ended with a negative bitcoin balance. An account cannot send coins it never received, so transactions were missing. The reports meant to prove a theft had been edited, and the on-chain record showed what they left out.

Part two · The money

The same cash-out, seven times.

His reports listed 11 addresses he had paid. Traced forward, the Ethereum ones kept doing the same thing: one address takes the money, splits it across fresh addresses within minutes, and each of those empties into an exchange.

SEPTEMBER 12, 2018 · 19 MINUTES
times in UTC
SOURCE
His Coinbase account
Sends 100 ETH at 14:28
FIRST HOP
0x26B3…52ed
Splits it 14:37 to 14:47
× 6
  • Private address 1< 3 minBinance deposit A
  • Private address 2< 3 minBinance deposit B
  • Private address 3< 3 minBinance deposit C
  • Private address 4< 3 minBinance deposit D
  • Private address 5< 3 minBinance deposit E
  • Private address 6< 3 minKuCoin deposit

Each private address emptied in full within three minutes of being funded. Five went to Binance, each to a different deposit address. The same deposit addresses also took money straight from other Coinbase accounts.

Every repeat, in order.

About 262 ETH from his Coinbase account, split across 53 fresh addresses, most of it landing at Binance. Three of the runs drew on a single address he had funded with 131 ETH.

  1. 01May 14 and 16, 2018
    8 ETH0x181A…9fFD6 addresseswithin 1 min
    Binance, Bibox, Bittrex
  2. 02May 19, 2018
    16.5 ETH0xf6af…45827 addresseswithin 2 min
    Binance
  3. 03May 21, 2018
    3.6 ETH0x16CC…819F3 addresseswithin minutes
    Binance
  4. 04May 24, 2018
    16.5 ETH0x7a06…633d13 addresseswithin 3 min
    Binance
  5. 05May 30, 2018
    100 ETH0x18E9…F49A12 addresseswithin minutes
    Binance, KuCoin, Kraken, Poloniex, Bittrex, YoBit
  6. 06August 19, 2018
    18 ETH0xf230…d2186 addresseswithin about 1 hour
    Binance, ShapeShift, KuCoin
  7. 07September 12, 2018
    100 ETH0x26B3…52ed6 addresseswithin 3 min
    Binance, KuCoin

One HitBTC deposit address kept coming back.

The largest transfer skipped the fan-out. 749 ETH went from his Coinbase account to a relay address that passed it almost straight to a single HitBTC deposit address. The tokens he had sold investors on, WAX among them, went to the same address, and another of his addresses fed it too.

TOKEN RELAYEthereum
Coinbase to the relay749.2 ETH, June 20 to 29, 2018
Relay0xE701…F16c
Relay to HitBTCAlmost all of the ETH, same days
Tokens sent onWAX, CMCT and TRX
HitBTC deposit0xA124…2be4
Also paid by0x75ab…3A76
WHAT WAS LEFT

Under $300 across every address he named.

Against a screenshot showing $37.8 million. The trail handed counsel a subpoena list: the wallet company, Binance, HitBTC and Bittrex, plus the other Coinbase accounts paying the same deposit addresses.

Part three · The man

We knew who he was. Not where he was.

Most cases start with a wallet and end with a name. This one started with the name. He had raised the money in New York under his own, and his investors, his creditors and regulators all knew it. What none of them knew was where he had gone. The chain could not say: every trail ended at an exchange. Off-chain work could.

WHERE HE WAS
off-chain
NEW YORK
LONDON
GIBRALTAR
ISRAEL
  • New York

    Where he raised the money, under his own name, and where the case was filed.

  • Gibraltar

    Tied to him off-chain after he left New York, on the edge of Spain.

  • Israel

    Tied to him off-chain, a second country outside US reach.

  • London

    Where the red notice caught him, passing through Heathrow.

Getting the money back meant getting him back first.

SUBPOENAS

Reach the exchanges, not the man

Binance, HitBTC, Bittrex and the wallet company could be asked who held the accounts. None of that puts him in a deposition chair.
CIVIL CASES

Stall when the defendant is abroad

Judgments and depositions are hard to enforce against someone who has left the country and does not plan to return.
CRIMINAL CASES

Travel with him

A criminal charge can carry an Interpol red notice, which asks police worldwide to find and hold a person for extradition. It works the moment he crosses a border.

The outcome

From a screenshot to a courtroom.

  1. 2017 to 2021

    Raises about $4.4 million from more than 250 investors. According to regulators, at most $447,300 goes into digital assets and at least $1.5 million goes to personal spending.

  2. 2020

    Leaves New York and settles in Spain.

  3. October 2021

    The $37.8 million screenshot is captured. He texts it to an investor the next month.

  4. 2022

    Files for bankruptcy and tells his creditors a hack took the funds, backed by edited transaction reports.

  5. 2022

    Our team takes the screenshot and the reports apart, traces the 11 addresses, and ties him off-chain to Gibraltar and Israel.

  6. September 2022

    A federal regulator files fraud charges in Manhattan.

  7. Later

    Wanted on an Interpol red notice, he is arrested while passing through London Heathrow and held in a London prison.

  8. Now

    Extradited to the United States, where he is on trial.

IN COURT

Arrested at Heathrow. Extradited. On trial.

The investors started with a screenshot, a story about a hack and a name. They ended with proof the screenshot and reports were doctored, a traced money trail, a subpoena list, a map of where he had been, and the man back in the United States to answer for it.

What made it work

Prove the claim false. Follow the habit. Find the man.

SCREENSHOTS

A screenshot is a claim

Rebuild the interface it came from and see what is missing. Here, six things were, and every one of them hid where the money really sat.
PATTERNS

Habits beat single hops

One fan-out to an exchange proves little. The same shape seven times, minutes apart, to the same exchange, is a signature.
OFF-CHAIN

Location is evidence too

The chain showed where the money landed. Only off-chain work showed where he was, and that decided which legal tools would work.

The same work today

Every step of this case, in one platform.

The trace, the person behind it and the case file now live in the same place, so the next one moves faster.

AUTO-TRACE

Fan-outs, followed to the deposit address →

Auto-trace follows splits like these through to the exchange deposit addresses, where a case turns into a subpoena or a freeze request.

OFF-CHAIN

The person, not just the wallet →

Search the email, phone or handle behind an account and see the profiles, posts and pages it connects to.

CASES

One case file for the whole team →

Pin the trace, the screenshot analysis and the timeline into one case that counsel and investigators work together.

  • The subject is not named and wallet addresses are shortened.
  • Investment figures come from public regulatory filings. The screenshot analysis and the trace come from our case file.
  • Charges are allegations. He is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

Bring us the screenshot.

Staged balances, edited reports, fan-outs to exchanges, a subject everyone can name but nobody can find. Our team and our platform have worked this case before.

Keep reading

Related pages